Fashion Police Files
 
Sat, 10th May 2008
Firebird purple

THE COSTUME INSTITUTE GALA BALL 2008 !!!

 Last Monday evening, the World’s Most Beautiful People, got together to celebrate Fashion with the staging of the Costume Institute Gala Ball 2008, at the prestigious Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York...

As this event has been co-chaired by US Vogue Editor, Anna Wintour, actress Julia Roberts, and actor George Clooney, for the last 13 years, we can assume that it is now considered to be the foremost event in New York’s Social Calendar...and at $7,500 per ticket, if you’re lucky enough to get an invitation in the first place, you had better be happy to dig deep...

 

As you can imagine, when this many famous people get together, all dolled up in their Designer finery, and when you factor in the added nuance of a Theme, you can almost guarantee that there will be a certain element of Fashion pratfalls amongst the Great and Good...and this year, the chosen theme was "Superheroes : Fashion & Fantasy"...

Hmmmm, just right for a series of Fantastic Fashion Blunders, you'd think...


THE WORST FASHION MISTAKES OF THE NIGHT...

The evening’s Theme was "Superheroes: Fashion & Fantasy" - a theme that would be fairly easy to interpret, in a fashion sort of way, you would think - so how many guests went for it in a big way?...

That’s right – almost no-one !! Sorry..

That is, except for Christina Ricci...

CHRISTINA RICCI

Christina chose a ravishingly awful Givenchy concoction, that I’m fairly certain wasn’t actually included in their latest Runway Show...

 

At least I couldn’t find it, and therefore, it is with a certain amount of disappointment that I have to conclude that Givenchy designer, Riccardo Tisci, actually designed this especially for her...

Now Christina was one of only a few people who had the guts to go with the actual theme in any way, shape or form, so I should give her credit for that, but for some absolutely unfathomable reason, this dress has had people gushing all over the Internet about how lovely it is, and how brave she was to interpret the evening’s theme with taste and sensibility !!

Stuff and nonsense I say – this dress is an absolute travesty of Good Taste, and should be consigned to the bin marked " Bad Fashion Student Projects" at once...and never spoken of again....

For one thing, the shiny, red, satin bodysuit that underpins the whole dress is uneven, and slightly lop-sided, around the top edge of the bodice, and so ruins somewhat, the Superwoman effect that Christine was trying for...and for another thing, the horrible pale pink netting is very unevenly attached to the bodice – you can even see the stitching that gathers it all together !!



The other thing that is bothering me about Christina, is that she is looking alarmingly thin – she is beginning to get that slightly bobble-headed Look, where celebrities who are underweight have heads that look too big for their bodies...

For God’s sake, eat something – OK ?!!

GISELLE BUNDCHEN

Giselle didn’t opt for the theme at all, unless she was going for a sort of "Supertart – all whims catered for and nothing too much trouble"...

This is a beautiful Versace dress that I actually featured in the RTW Collections post this Spring, alongside a whole lot of dresses from the same Collection that I just knew would turn up on a Red Carpet somewhere, but I didn’t bank on it being quite so revealing – did Giselle have a word with Donatella, and get her to make it a little more open everywhere ?!!

You decide:-


Versace Runway...                                                       Giselle...

What d’you think ? Did she phone Donatella up and ask for a slight alteration, or am I mistaken - is this dress as revealing as it appears to be in real life ?

VICTORIA BECKHAM

Everybody’s favourite Fashion Victim didn’t let us down last Monday evening...on the face of it, a supremely elegant 40s inspired look...

 

But when you get close in, it turns out to be rather less than it seems... 

Victoria tried to wow them in a vintage Armani ( Autumn Collection ’89 ) 40s style, see-through negligee, split to the thigh, with square shoulders, long sleeves and the severest make-up job ever...

 

She pouted and posed, and generally tried to convince us all that she is a Fashion Icon, but I'm not convinced...

C’mon Posh - would it kill you to smile a little ?...

 MARY-KATE OLSEN

Both the Olsen twins were there, but as usual, it is Mary-Kate that has taken my interest...

 

Her Diana Von Furstenburg dress is actually not bad – a little droopy, but then it is covered with gold sequins as if to make up for her lack of sparkle – so it’s probably quite heavy, but it isn’t that bad...her shoes could be a size smaller too, but on the whole, the actual seperate components of her Look are good....

She, however, looks dreadful !!

She looks so out of it, I do wonder if she hasn’t just paid a little visit to the Ladies for a quick fix....

ROSIE HUNTINGTON-WHITELY

Who??? I hear you all shout...

Rosie is a very sought after top model, from an aristocratic background – a well-bred young lady indeed, who is carving a very nice career for herself out of wearing daft dresses to fashion parties, accompanying the designer...

Here, she is modelling a Burberry dress that looks like it is made out of an entire flock of birds, and dyed the most disgusting colour combination of black, fading into midnight-blue, which in turn fades into dove-grey, finishing with yellow-ochre down at the hem...the colour-scheme from Hell indeed !!

If it wasn’t made entirely out of feathers, it might be passable, but the fact that it is, just makes it one of the worst dresses I’ve seen for a very long time...

Poor Rosie...she probably didn’t have much choice in which dress she was going to wear to this do, for if she had, she surely would have picked something different...something a little more elegant perhaps ?!!

WENDI MURDOCH

Wife to the newspaper tycoon, Rupert Murdoch, Wendi is proving that having loads of spare cash does not give you Good Taste...


Here, she is wearing a vaguely 18th Century-inspired concoction by Christian Lacroix, who, let’s face it, is possibly the only Designer who would create something like this...

First of all, I’m really fond of the black and blue combination, on anything...secondly, this dress simply looks cumbersome – it has none of the grace we have come to expect from a modern Ball-gown these days...it is too structured, too heavy, and too bejewelled...

But that is just my own taste – you, of course, may love it to bits...

Or not !!

SCARLETT JOHANSSEN

Scarlett has got her picture on most magazines and onto most of the fashion website pages, because of her recent engagement and because she is a popular face to photograph...

 

I do wish, however, she would lighten up her taste in dresses a little, and give her bosom a little welcome relief...I mean, they always look so restrained, pushed up, and boned in...

She is a very pretty girl, but she doesn’t do herself any favours at all, and it pains me to see her in such awful drab colours too...she would look stunning in clear blues and aqua-greens, but do we ever see her in such gorgeous shades ? – no, we do not !!



This dress is by Dolce & Gabbana, who are given to designing dresses with huge skirts, that make you look about two sizes bigger than you probably are, and this dress is no exception...I thought it unflatteringly boring in colour, and resembling a corset up top...you can see all the stitched boning lines – how unflattering is that ?!!

SAMANTHA BOARDMAN-ROSEN

Another New York Socialite, whose life revolves around the NY Party scene...she went to Giambattista Valli for her party frock...

 

She resembles a giant red bubble, that may just go whizzing around the ceiling if you undid her air valve...it really does look like someone has pumped her up with a bicycle pump, doesn’t it?!!

KATIE HOLMES

Katie also went for a vintage frock, and quite a nice one too actually...like Posh’s dress, this one is by Armani too, but this time from the Autumn Collection of ’93...do you reckon, by any chance, that she and her New Best Friend, Victoria Beckham went shopping together for their frocks ? To the same vintage store ?!! Seems too much of a coincidence to be true otherwise, doesn’t it...

Anyway, as I was saying, this dress is quite nice actually, but what I am taking issue with are the choice of royal blue shoes....

True, they are designed by Christian Louboutin ( who else ?!! ) but they are BLUE ... not the best choice for a bright red dress, I wouldn’t have thought...mind you, the theme of this Ball was Superheroes...maybe she is trying desperately to channel her inner Superwoman...

 

The other thing is the necklace - why, oh why, do these people try and make a long dangly necklace work with a beautiful strapless bodice, when, clearly, a choker or short necklace would have been so much better....it wouldn’t interfere with the top edge of the bodice and it definitely wouldn’t fall outside of one boob, making her look somewhat lopsided - not a Good Look !!

KATHERINE NEAL SHAFFER

Now then, here we see the most common mistake that guests at this do made with the theme...either they went all out for it and wore something ridiculously amateurish, and ever so slightly fancy-dress-ish, like Christina Ricci...or they tried to interpret the Superheroes Theme in a more understated and subtle way, whilst keeping their evening dress quite elegant, and end up looking a little bit – well, you know – kinky...
Here is Katherine wearing her lovely Alberta Ferretti dress with its pretty bodice, and elegant Empire-line cut...

 
However, she has seen fit to team it with a frankly, bizarre choice of footwear – she is definitely channelling her Inner Emma Peel with these thigh-high boots, and I’ll be willing to bet that she will wish she hadn’t bothered when the photos appeared in the Press, and all over the Internet, the next day...

LISA PERRY & DAUGHTER

To my shame,. I can’t find out the name of Lisa’s daughter, but never mind, my attention is really on Lisa herself...

 

She is a Fashion Designer who is very much influenced by 60s fashion – her latest Collection resembles the earliest designs by Mary Quant, and so it comes as no surprise that Lisa entered the spirit of this Gala Ball Theme with a vengeance too - hurrah !!

I’m so glad she did...

Her outfit is as entertaining as it is nutty, and long may she continue designing stuff like this to wear to social events of this calibre – she should have designed some of the other dresses too – at least they would have been amusing instead of just dreadful...

I particularly love the white plastic boots...FAB !!!

For my last Dreadful Dress, I shall go for a person who is fast developing into my favourite Worst Dress contender, a woman who is almost consistently on my list...

TILDA SWINTON

This is perfectly marvellous...

For one thing she is wearing make-up...yes, that’s right, I’ll just repeat that for those of you who have fainted dead away...

Tilda Swinton has got the lipstick out...
 

And what an improvement it is too...she looks somewhat healthier now !!

The only thing is that the rest of her new-found love of cosmetics runs to wearing what looks like a gold mask done in eye-shadow...no doubt running with the "Superheroes" Theme of the Ball !!

Her dress is a real Grandmother dress – as dowdy as you could possibly get, without being the Queen herself...and what makes me wince is that she is actually two years younger than me...but manages to look a good two decades older...so if you have fantastic red hair, it helps to keep up the illusion enormously, if you make sure you touch up the roots before you sweep it up high on your head...

Her companion is her friend, the drag artiste Justin Bond, who, touchingly, has chosen to wear the same shoes as Tilda, but in a different colour...

So, these then were the worst outfits that this Gala Ball threw up, in the general direction of the waiting Press....so what d’you think ?

Is it really a Good idea to give a Ball like this such a difficult Theme, for people to make fools of themselves over, whilst the more sensible ones just ignore it...

Or should they just stick to definite Fashion-orientated Themes, like last year’s fantastic 1920’s celebration of Paul Poiret, or neutral themes like the year before, when they did the Anglomania thing ?....

Or perhaps not bother with a theme at all, and just let everyone dress up to the nines, like they do with the Oscars ?

In the next post, I will look at the first half of the Best Dresses, of which there were so many truly gorgeous examples, that I have had to break it down into two posts...

 



 

Comments 
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I believe KATIE HOLMES may have been going for the 'wonder girl look' whose colors are red and royal blue.

I think Christina Ricci's ensemble would look better in different colors.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Mystee,
Oh yes - undoubtedly, that was her train of thought...still, her outfit is what prompted my musings about the nature of the theme for this Ball, in the first place, and whether last year's theme worked a whole lot better...still, it is all dependant on what the Costume Institute's Annual big Exhibition is...and this year, it is the Role of the Cult of the Superhero on Fashion Design...so that is what we got...

Christina's ensemble would have looked a whole lot better if it had been more professionally made - it looked like she had banged it together the previous night whilst drunk...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Victoria is, at least, looking better here than some of her other more recent choices of costume and the feather dress of Rosie is almost fun. I wouldn't say the colours are too horrid.

I also personally think Katie Holmes looks swell in that combination.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Lollaping,
Do you know, when I first saw Victoria's outfit, I thought "Oh wow !!!" - I really did like it at first...the swept up hairdo is sophisticated, the cream lace, and the square shoulders were quite an original Look, in this day and age...
However, then I saw every picture of her with the same hard, pouty expression on her face, at all the different places to be photgraphed, so it wasn't all at one Press Opportunity...then I noticed that the dressing gown was actually see through, and she isn't wearing any kind of bra...surely she would know of the power of your average flashbulb !!!

As for Katie Holmes, I like her dress - it's really beautiful, but I really hate the shoes with it - they are too contrasty a colour, but having said that, I really think Mystee is correct - it's the Wonderwoman colour scheme that she is evoking...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Oh my god. When I looked at that first picture of Mary-Kate Olsen I thought she was an 80-year-old woman!!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I had the exact same thought!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I've seen many reviewers loving Christina Ricci's dress, but I am with you - it just doesn't work, at least in my view. It looks awkward and the colors don't work for me.

I like the Katie Holmes look...it seemed the blue shoes were deliberately playing on the superheroes theme, so I didn't mind them.

Victoria Beckham...good lord, if she is trying to avoid laugh lines by adopting that permanent sour puss, I wish she would stop, already! Smile, dammit, smile! *g*

The Scarlett Johansson has actually grown on me over time viewing it, although I agree the color doesn't do anything for her, nor does her hair style.

Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Peri,
I really can't think what everyone is raving about, with Christina's dress - I, too, really hate that awful pale pink netting...unless it's really that she was only one of a very few people who bothered with the theme at all...out of the ones who did, she is the most obvious, except for Anna Wintour, whose dress has to go down as one of the Marvels of the Modern World, I think...such a concoction !!

Everyone looked at Katie's blue shoes and went "WTF ???!!!"
Then everyone worked it out, me included, but it took time to dawn on me, and really, if you are going to interpret a theme for a party, it should be immediately obvious to everyone...don't you think ?

The day Victoria actually laughs for the World's Press, is the day I take this site down...because it isn't going to happen !!!

As for Scarlett, she is such a pretty girl - it's a shame that she isn't really knowing what suits her at the stage in her life when she really ought to make the most of her looks...they aren't going to last, as Mews says below...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Mary Kate looks 40 years old. So sad. And Scarlett isn't going to age well. She seems to choose the most unflattering colors she can find.

I did find Lisa Perry's outfit amusing and interesting. Her daughter looks lovely, I think.

And Tilda. How I wish she'd wear something beautiful and elegant in some rich jewel color. She'd look like a queen.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Mews,
I agree with you on every point, especially Tilda...how stunning, she would look in a richer colour, especially with her chosen hair colour which is just FAB !!...here she is at the Edinburgh Festival a few years ago, and how lovely she looks in a darker shade...



Lisa's outfit was tremendous fun - how I wish that more guests had interpreted the theme in such a fun way, and worn similar stuff - what a great post I would have to put up ( not that this isn't great, but you know what I mean ) - and if you are famous as an actress, it wouldn't take that much nerve - it's just like playing a role, isn't it ?!!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I'm not sure what's up with that Mary-Kate girl, but having loved her in all of the old Olsen movies, I'm somewhat ashamed by how she's taken stardom. She could use a shower here, I think? The first time I saw that, I wondered if she'd just hopped out of bed, or been into something much worse. I'm also wondering if Tilda and Mary-Kate have been sharing tips? Tilda was wonderfully scary in Narnia, yes, but I do wonder about her off screen.
Honestly, I think Lisa Perry's outfit is magnificent, merely for the fact that it had me laughing. It's so 60s superhero style (other than being a dress) that I find myself loving it.
And Victoria Beckham's style has got me wondering where Posh Spice went. I can't see her in herself anymore, haha. I can imagine she'd be quite beautiful if she would smile, however.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Cailte,
I have never seen any of Mary-Kate's acting work, but I reckon she is really pretty under the droopy, beshadowed eyelids, and the druggy look that she has had for the last few years or so...

As for Lisa's outfit, I'm with you on that one - it is a fab interpretation - crazy in the same camp way that the old sci-fi tv shows from the late sixties were..."Flash Gordon" and the like - and the only reason it is in here is that it follows the original plan for this post - that this first post would be all the crazy, mad stuff that I was sure was bound to ensue with such a theme...however, I was sadly mistaken, wasn't I ?!!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I am such a avid despiser of Katie Holmes that I find this hard to say, but I actually quite adored the outfit. I am also married to one of the world's biggest comic book nerds, so believe me, I know my comics whether I want to or not! I think Katie did a cute job wearing something elegant and adding something fun that she would never get to do ordinarily wear (I hope).

I also think that Christina Ricci's gown could have been fantastic, but you're right...it was just off. Maybe if it was made over the course of a couple of weeks instead of in thirty minutes? 'Cause that's what it looks like.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Vidyate,
"I am such a avid despiser of Katie Holmes that I find this hard to say, "
Blimey - what's she done to deserve such venom ?!!
Well, I do know what it is to be simply irritated to death, by someone, that I can't actually bear to see them or hear them anywhere...so I think I know what you mean really !!

As for Christina's dress, yes - I really wish it had been executed better, and with a different coloured netting, etc, etc...

Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Lisa Perry's daughter is very pretty and she's wearing a nice dress.

Cristina Ricci? In a nice outfit? *snort*

The superhero theme is an excellent choice and Im just so disappointed that more people didn't dress up (Wonder Woman Rocks).

Oh and before I forget.

Scarlett Johanssen. Would someone please explain her appeal? She's stunning but she does herself no favours and always ends up looking odd and poorly dressed.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Mizmalice,
Lisa Perry's daughter is also wearing a Lisa Perry Original design, and it is fab too, but in a slightly more sophisticated way...it looks more like a proper party dress than Lisa's humourous take on the theme...

"The superhero theme is an excellent choice and Im just so disappointed that more people didn't dress up (Wonder Woman Rocks).
"

Yes, well, I agree - I really thought that there would be more 'entering-into-the-spirit' of the given Theme-thing going on, however, it seems that
when it comes to being photographed by the World's Press, yer average actress can't possibly be seen without being dressed elegantly and looking a million dollars...although I think that Anna Wintour, the Organiser from hell as one jounalist put it, was exercising a certain amount of veto power overwhat guests were going to be wearing...even she put on something 'absolutely-fab-in-a-sci-fi-way' though !!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I think Giselle's dress just looks so much more revealing because her skin is so much more tan than the model's, contrasting to the shade of the dress so much more.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Pinkielephant,
You could be right about that - when I went back to get the Runway photo, it appears to be every bit as revealing on the model, as it is on Giselle..so maybe I'm wrong about that !!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Re: Giselle Bundchen - I think the only reason that dress looks more revealing on Giselle is that she's more tanned and has bigger boobs. It's a very revealing dress on the original model too - but since she's so painfully skinny and pale (almost the same colour as the dress), it's not as obvious
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Shriker tam,
Hi and welcome to this journal...

Yes - you must have posted your comment almost at the same time as Pinkie above you, as you make the same point...you are probably right !! The Runway models are so skinny these days that it's amazing that anything is revealed at all...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Hmm, I really wish everyone had gone nuts with the theme. Then bad outfits would be a lot more forgivable, I think.

Victoria Beckham looks so much older than she is. Seriously, she looks like a 60-year-old woman who's had too many facelifts in an effort to keep her young beau around. Terrible.

And Katie Holmes' facial expressions are just bizarre.
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Wait, I've got it! Perhaps those two are trying to portray supervillains! That would explain Beckham's severity and Holmes' smirk!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
I saw several of these on the "Get Fugly" blog and didn't realize there was a theme... now some of them make so much more sense!

Katie Holmes... Pretty hideous color combo, but it definitely goes with the theme, I think. Can't stand her makeup, or hair, though.

Scarlett... It seemed cute at first, but the color is definitely not flattering, and her hair looks pretty bad, too.

Mary-Kate... I think she's the worst. She looks 80. Her hair's a tangled, frizzy mess. Her dress is horrid, in my opinion. The gold just adds to her looking three times older than she really is.

I too wish Victoria would smile. But in that dress, she also looks ancient.

Wendi Murdoch's dress is interesting. I don't like the bottom part of the skirt, but if the blue portion continued and wasn't nearly as poofy, it might be elegant.

Giselle... I think the dress fits the runway model better, or you're right and she had it made a size too small. Giselle has the side-boob hanging out, which is never really attractive, to me anyway.

And Christina... I'm not a fan. It looks sloppy.
Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Do you mean this blog :-

http://gofugyourself.typepad.com/

I am a big fan of theirs, and indeed, get quite a few of my pictures from them...particularly the regular Worst Fashion Disasters of the Year Post that I do, every January...

All these people add up to the worst outfits or looks of the night, in my opinion, but there were plenty more dresses that were just so-so - boring in colour, or designs that I had seen a million times before, so I was quite ruthless in cutting it down to these ones only...all the points you made are exactly what I didn't like about these outfits too, and in the case of Victoria Beckham and Mary-Kate Olsen, it was more a case of general composure and expression, or lack of it...

Victoria, in particular, needs a bloody good joke told to her, to get her to crack that expression of, what she considers to be, a Fashion Icon Look, but what everyone else sees as a supercilious, and somewhat bored, glare...no-one likes it, and no-one sees her as the Fashion Icon that she fancies herself as, so why doesn't someone tell her that she would be so much more liked and respected if she looked natural, and let her personality shine through - I'm pretty sure she has one somewhere in there !!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
okay that christina ricci dress is terrible, i understand how it could have looked amazing but that much bum on the red carpet is too much

i have yet to see victoria in something i like that doesn't show everything or suck everything in too tight

yick i thought mary-kate wasn't part of the drug taking lindsay lohan troup, it appears i was mistaken

that wendi murdoch dress i swear is one of the most unflattering things i've seen since i started watching your blog

erm..i actually quite like scarlett's dress but it doesn't look right on her for some reason..i think you're right about the colours she is washing herself right out!

i despise katie's dress an the shoes make it worse , but i'm biased as i hate orange

hehe i love that crazy white thing lisa perry has-i love how designers can get away with looking like nuts! by the way her daughter looks beautiful there

yes tilda i knew she'd pop up, she looks like she has grey around her eyebrows :S

Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Gloomy,
Victoria may get a post of her own, one of these days - I have so many incriminating Fashion Disaster pics concerning her in so many awful Fashion Victim outfits, particularly involving painfully tight boning, or so much boob upthrust that she looks like she's going to take off...she makes me laugh every time I see her in some new outfit, and as for her Fashion Advice book - well, the less said, the better !!

Lisa Perry - I hadn't heard of her before this post, but it always feels great to discover someone who is clearly as mad as a hatter...loopy fashion designers are definitely my favourite post-fodder...I love their unpredictability and their general "I can get away with this because I designed it" attitude !!

As for Wendi Murdoch's Lacroix creation, his dresses get featured almost everytime someone wears one to a Red Carpet Function - he is so over-the-top with the heavy jewelling and the exaggerated historical shapes, that it's inevitable...it's very brave, therefore, for anyone to wear one of his dresses...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Scarlett's absolutely stunning, with a figure to die for and yet time and time again she chooses dresses in this odd washed-out colour that does nothing for her. I'm sure she wore a similar style of dress in a similar colour a couple of years ago...it didn't suit her then and you'd think she'd have learned!
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Oooh, what a collection! Ricci's pink dress hurts my eyes, precioussss. :)

Olsen just looks scary. Very, very scary. :(

Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Mary-Kate Olsen looks completely out of it...she loooks like she has just come off a three week bender with her other druggy mates...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Oh dear. I am both quite horrified about their choices in dresses and very much amused by your comments.

ROSIE HUNTINGTON-WHITELY's was maybe my nightmare of these ones, I mean, totally agree with you about the horrible horrible colours!

GISELLE BUNDCHEN would have saved a lot of money if she had just bought some wide pieces of cloth and pinned them together. The dress looks so different from the runway one reveal-wise.

Thank you, once again, for a great post and keeping me updated what happens in the world gala-wise as I'm such a lazy person when it comes to following any news!!
Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Pigeonnaire,
Rosie's dress may not have been her choice, as she possibly might have been a guest of the Burberry Designer, and given the dress to wear - this is how it works to this Ball quite often - the designers invite top models to wear something from their Collections, and get photographed by the Press - added publicity you see !! I don't know whether this was the case with Rosie, but I hate her dress - it would have been so much better of it had stayed with gradually lightening shades of that beautiful, purpley-indigo all the way down - that would have been sensational, in my view...
Sat, 10th May 2008 (UTC)
Katie Holmes' getup was actually one that I did not find. It seemed kitschy enough to fit in with the theme of the evening.

Victoria disappoints me though. Why so..matronly? This is like the opposite of the Posh Spice epitome! I half-expected her to come dressed up as Wonder Woman or SuperGirl or Catwoman...or something equally FUN, you know? *sigh*

Christina's ensemble looks good from afar but not so much close-up...the concept is interesting enough and I believe that it has the potential to be pretty. I agree that she's getting dreadfully (or standard Hollywood startlet-size) thin nowadays. :/

I don't think that Giselle's dress was altered, but I do believe that she has slightly..ampler assets than Carmen Kass who wore in on the runway. I wish that she had bothered to dress it up a bit more, to keep up with the theme of the evening...

I remember those good ol' days where Scarlett would wear reds, teals and deep, vibrant colors...her fashion sense has gotten less interesting with time (and media exposure). :(

Oh Lisa Perry, you crazy maverick! Lol, at least she is truly channeling her 60's inner superhero! Lol.

Tilda does have gorgeous dark green shoes. I believe that the colour would look ravishing on her if she wore it for a dress!

Can't wait to see your best-dressed! There were, indeed, many lovely dresses adn lovely ladies!
Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Betsyli,
Now then - Victoria as Catwoman - that would have been FAB !!!

The Best-dressed list is currently running to about thirty outfits - so I may have to do some pruning...and I may also do a Mens post as well...
Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Victoria B looks hard as nails. I must be one of the few who likes Wendi's dress. Well, I like the colour and the wild look of it - I think she carries it off. Whereas poor Scarlett does look like she's raided a dress-up box.
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
Peachy,

Yes, I agree - Victoria never looks any different though !! She always has this semi-pouting expression, as if she is posing for any camera that may be within lens distance of her...

Poor Scarlett and the dressing up box - pity she forgot to select a dress to go over her underwear...
Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
Now I don't know what dress could Tilda Swinton looks good! Maybe her masculine look doesn't really fit her taste of fashion...

Mary Kate needs some counselling! On fashion, of course. :)
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
Heather,
Well, I think that although Tilda does have a slightly masculine look, she could look absolutely stunning in something very tailored, but in a rich jewel-coloured velvet, say...the shoes she is wearing are a good example of the kind of rich colour I have in mind, and the photo I posted in a comment up further just goes to illustrate what I mean....because of her choice of red hair colour, anything in the blues/greens/greys spectrum would just look great on her...
Sun, 11th May 2008 (UTC)
I really like Cristina Ricci's dress. It keeps up with the theme, and it's not that bad. Also Lisa Perry's outfit is...interesting. I also liked Giselle's dress. It just fits her perfectly and shows off everything it's supposed to and nothing more.


Katie Holmes looked absolutely awfull! That dress is so weird and the makeup is waay too much. It makes her look 80 or something. She really should take fashion tips from someone else. And Scarlet Johansson looks like she forgot to put on her dress.
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
Black Panther,
To Christina's great credit is the fact that she did actually go with the theme, unlike a whole lot of other people...'tis a shame that the technical finish on this dress wasn't as goodas it could have been - so amateurish really - and the pale pink colour a tad darker - otherwise it probably could have been great !!
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
I swear most of them look like they are going to the circus lol!

And Victoria Beckman looks like she always does.
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
Luvhergurl,

Hahaha - circus, yes !!!
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
Hey Wendy,

I think Giselle's dress wasn't altered - or maybe just the Slightest Bit - but she's curvier than the runway model, so it just looks that way.

Victoria's looks better than most of them! It seems a little better suited for the bedroom to me, and not terribly super hero - ish, but it could definitely be worse!

Agreed - MK looks dreadful! And poor Rosie, having to wear that awful thing.

I think Scarlett's isn't bad... the color is boring, and I'm not fond of that kind of skirt, but I think the corset-tops are sexy. I love to tight lace myself, though.

Katie is looking fab, but the shoes are a little shocking! Superwoman or no - perhaps she could have tied them in better with some blue jewelry or a handbag? Maybe not.

Lisa's costume is adorable! It's flattering and costume like, not like some of the others.

I've never thought Tilda was attractive - but the way she dresses only makes it worse. My great grandmother might have worn that dress, minus the bright orange star!


I do love the costume that covers the cut though; I hope the whole thing is posted in the best dressed!

Edited at 2008-05-12 03:49 am (UTC)
Mon, 12th May 2008 (UTC)
Anna,

"Victoria's looks better than most of them! It seems a little better suited for the bedroom to me, and not terribly super hero - ish, but it could definitely be worse!"

Oh definitely - if it wsn't so see-through, which I think is always a big mistake on a Red Carpet, it would be fabulously elegant and very vampish in a totally 30s / 40s kind of way... however, it is the see-through bit I objected to, and the fact that she doesn't ever look like she is enjoying herself - at all, ever !!

" think Scarlett's isn't bad... the color is boring, and I'm not fond of that kind of skirt, but I think the corset-tops are sexy. I love to tight lace myself, though."

I don't mind the odd proper corset-bodice at all, especially a laced up one - at least you can see that it is supposed to be a dress, but it is the combination of the corset stitching and the horrible flesh-coloured underwear shade, that made me wince once again !!

" do love the costume that covers the cut though; I hope the whole thing is posted in the best dressed!"

Oh no, LOL - that is Michelle Pfeiffer as Catwoman in the 1992 Batman movie, "Batman Returns" - the costume she wore was just FAB, and it would have livend up proceedings enormously if anyone HAD worn this...
Tue, 13th May 2008 (UTC)
I think the feather dress would look considerably better if the bottom end with a lighter grey or an almost white color.

Tilda Swinton looks like she was trying to be a tame version of Ziggy Stardust with her hair styled like that and her bad makeup.

Lisa Perry looks so terrific in comparison to everyone else. Her outfit looks so fun and I really love her purse!

Fri, 16th May 2008 (UTC)
It's not the dresses, it's the faces. Poor Ashley look's like she's at Death's door. It wouldn't much matter what she had on. The same goes for Tilda with that jaundice-looking gold stuff around her eyes and stiff hair. She looks like she could be the mother of the killer in Psycho, but already dead and stuffed. I don't hate the dress, but it's no good on her. The orange starfish looks like someone pelted it at her and it stuck there. Love the shoes, although they look hellishly uncomfortable.

Christina Ricci's looking incredibly svelte and her face looks beautiful. I wouldn't say "alarmingly thin", or not for a celebrity. She looks thin for her, since she's been curvier and plumper. The dress is bad. I hate its lopsided front and the transparent stuff looks like something that was crumpled in a too-hot dryer. The red part looks like something made from that fake taffeta that smells bad.

I think Giselle B. looks great in that dress, but I fail to see what it has to do with the event. It's slinky and glamorous, but nothing to do with superheroes.

Peachy said above that Scarlet looked like she'd raided the dress-up box; that's good! I agree with you that it's a bad colour for her. For anyone, perhaps.

I think you're right about Katie Holmes, too. Perhaps as someone said the blue shoes were a nod to the superhero theme, but it just didn't work, and as you pointed out the necklace is very wrong for it. I do think that she herself looks glossy and lovely in the pictures, if with too much spray-on tan.

As usual, this was very enjoyable, Wendy.

Edited at 2008-05-16 06:40 pm (UTC)